Green Builder Media

Are We There Yet?

Written by Sara Gutterman | Nov 19, 2026, 12:38:55 PM

Tariffs and immigration policy have hit the housing market hard. Is there hope on the horizon? 

Housing has spent three years in the bear’s grip, through rate spikes, tariff whiplash, labor shortfalls, and a market that seems permanently stuck in second gear. Everyone in the industry is asking the same question—is it time to feel some cautious optimism?

The answer: perhaps. In the days after the midterm elections, homebuilder stocks including Lennar, PulteGroup, and D.R. Horton jumped as much as 8% in a single day of trading, and Home Depot and Lowe’s rallied right alongside them. Mortgage applications rose 6.2% in the week ending November 6, the sharpest weekly increase since June, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

And while those rallies were temporarily encouraging, there are still underlying market fundamentals to contend with.

Where Relief Could Come From

Three forces have done more than any others to push up the cost of building a home over the past two years: tariffs, the war with Iran, and a shrinking construction workforce. Policy shifts in these areas could bring real relief to the housing market.

1. Tariffs

In an April 2025 NAHB survey, builders estimated that tariff actions had added about $10,900 to the cost of a typical home. Some of that pressure has already eased.

The Supreme Court has struck down tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, and in late October the administration lifted some tariffs on Canadian imports, including plywood. Other duties remain in place, including Section 232 tariffs on softwood lumber, steel, aluminum and copper, and a 25% tariff on imported kitchen cabinets and vanities that runs through the end of 2026.

Pending in Congress, the Housing Tariff Exclusion Act, would automatically exempt many building materials from current and future tariffs and create a process to exempt others. The Homebuilding Materials Tariff Relief Act would exempt critical home construction products from tariffs imposed since January 2025. If either moves forward when the new Congress convenes, builders could recover thousands of dollars per home and gain the pricing certainty that has been missing for two years.

2. Energy

Since the war began on February 28, oil prices have whipsawed with every headline, and the housing industry has felt it. Petroleum-based products include asphalt shingles, spray foam and rigid insulation, PVC pipe and siding, adhesives, sealants, and roofing membranes. Diesel moves every truckload of lumber and drywall and powers the equipment on most job sites.

By March, construction materials prices were up 4.8% year over year, the largest annual increase since early 2023, according to Associated Builders and Contractors, and diesel later climbed to record highs.

Since the election, oil has fallen sharply on hopes for a settlement, then rebounded as talks stalled, leaving prices well above where they stood before the war. A durable end to the conflict and a full reopening of the Strait of Hormuz would bring relief in two stages. Diesel and freight costs would ease within weeks. Petroleum-based materials would follow more slowly, because those prices lag crude by months and are already locked into supply chains. Builders should plan for gradual relief rather than an overnight reset.

3. Labor

Immigrant workers make up more than a quarter of the construction workforce, and government data indicate the industry is short roughly 300,000 workers. Builders report that stepped-up enforcement has kept even legally authorized workers off job sites in some markets.

In South Texas, builders say a typical 2,000-square-foot home that once took about four months to complete now takes up to nine. Every extra month adds carrying costs that eventually land in the price of the home.

Several workforce proposals have bipartisan support. Rep. Monica De La Cruz (R-Texas) is championing the Essential Workers for Economic Advancement Act, which would create a new H-2C visa designed for construction, a sector with no year-round guest worker program today.

The administration also authorized nearly 65,000 supplemental H-2B visas for fiscal year 2026. Housing industry economists assert that a durable legal pathway for construction workers would shorten cycle times, steady trade pricing and give builders the confidence to start more homes.

Taken together, lower tariffs, cheaper energy, and a steadier workforce could take meaningful cost out of every new home and give the industry some breathing room. But these relief levers won’t fix housing affordability on its own. Land, financing, insurance, and a structural shortage of homes will still be with us.

Builders who use any relief to reinvest in homes that are higher performance, more resilient, healthier, energy independent and cost less to own will be in the strongest position as the market balances out. Those who simply pocket it will be right back where they started the next time costs spike—on the lowest-first-cost race to the bottom—a viscous cycle that nobody wins.

Market Realities

Single-family starts remain constrained even though buyer demand is real. High land costs, sticky labor shortages and stubborn material prices have pushed builders to lean on mortgage rate buydowns and smaller floor plans to keep homes moving, and those tools come straight out of margin.

Meanwhile, the remodeling market has become the industry’s shock absorber. The typical American home is now more than 40 years old, and Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies projects owner-occupied improvement and repair spending to stay near historic highs of about $525 billion. Millions of homeowners locked into low mortgage rates are choosing to improve the home they have instead of trading up, which keeps kitchens, baths, exteriors and outdoor living in steady demand.

And, given these economic times, homeowners have become sharper accountants. In COGNITION Smart Data’s latest resiliency research, 71.3% of consumers said they are likely or very likely to invest in features that lower their long-term costs.

Dynamics to Watch

  • Policy follow-through. Whether tariff exclusions, a construction visa program, and buyer incentives move when the new Congress convenes in January.

  • Oil and the Iran war. Whether a lasting settlement brings diesel and petroleum-based material prices down, and how quickly suppliers pass the savings along.

  • The rate thaw. If mortgage rates continue to ease, pent-up demand could return quickly. Brands that invest in channel relationships and supply chain capacity now will be ready for it.

  • Insurance pricing. Premiums and availability will increasingly determine where and how homes get built.

  • Remodeling momentum. An aging housing stock keeps the repair-and-remodel market strong, especially for performance and resilience upgrades.

  • The value conversation. Products and homes that can quantify total cost of ownership will win the buyers who are now doing full-cost and total-value math.

So, Are We There Yet?

Not quite. Anyone promising a quick arrival is probably trying to sell you something. What we do have is a much clearer map: where the costs are coming from, what homeowners will pay for, and which builders and brands are positioned for the next cycle.

I’ll walk through that map in our 2026 State of the Industry Webinar: The New Affordability Equation, on Tuesday, December 1, at 2 p.m. ET. I’ll share the latest COGNITION Smart Data on how policy changes are likely to affect the housing sector, the challenges and opportunities builders are facing, shifting consumer expectations, and the market pull for Value Per Square Foot. Most importantly, we’ll look at the opportunities ahead and practical ways to future-proof your business.

Reserve your seat today!